# sgClaw Scene Skill Real Sample Validation Roadmap Design

> **Status:** Draft
> **Date:** 2026-04-18
> **Author:** Codex
> **Upstream Plan:** [2026-04-18-scene-skill-post-roadmap-execution-plan.md](D:/data/ideaSpace/rust/sgClaw/claw-new/docs/superpowers/plans/2026-04-18-scene-skill-post-roadmap-execution-plan.md)

## Problem Statement

The completed `60-to-90 roadmap` established repo-local promoted baselines for `G2`, `G1-E`, and `G3`, but the next quality barrier is no longer family promotion.

It is now real-sample validation:

1. `G2` already has a real mismatch anchor.
2. `G1-E` already has a real pass anchor.
3. `G3` is now selected into the real-sample queue but still lacks an executed real-run record.
4. `G6/G7/G8` remain boundary families until runtime gaps are explicitly closed.

The next roadmap must therefore be validation-first instead of asset-first.

## Goal

Define the next bounded roadmap around three immediate goals:

1. convert current selected real samples into formal pass/mismatch/fail-closed records
2. use validation pressure to decide whether boundary families or deferred families should enter implementation
3. keep execution-board work subordinate to validation rather than growing into a new asset program

## Scope

This roadmap includes:

1. real-sample execution for currently selected `G2/G1-E/G3` anchors
2. validation-result-driven scope decisions for `G6/G7/G8`
3. entry decisions for `G4/G5` only after explicit criteria are met

This roadmap does not include:

1. reopening completed repo-local compiler work for `G1/G2/G3`
2. unlimited fixture expansion
3. full 102-scene runtime rollout
4. direct implementation of all runtime gaps in one round

## Design Principles

1. Real-sample validation is the primary execution axis.
2. Execution-board changes must only exist to support validation records.
3. Boundary-family expansion must be justified by validation pressure, not drift.
4. Deferred-family entry must be decided explicitly before implementation begins.

## Workstream Model

1. `WS1` Mainline Real Sample Execution
2. `WS2` Validation Result Triage And Scope Decisions
3. `WS3` Boundary Runtime Enablement Decision
4. `WS4` Deferred Family Entry Decision

## Completion Criteria

This roadmap is complete when:

1. `G2`, `G1-E`, and `G3` each have executed real-sample records
2. the next implementation scope is selected from validation evidence
3. boundary-family and deferred-family entry decisions are documented before new implementation begins