claw/docs/superpowers/reports/2026-04-19-real-sample-validation-triage-report.md

Real Sample Validation Triage Report

Date: 2026-04-19 Roadmap: docs/superpowers/plans/2026-04-18-scene-skill-real-sample-validation-roadmap-plan.md

1. Triage Result

The three current mainline anchors now classify as:

1. G2: mismatch-driven
2. G1-E: stable
3. G3: mismatch-driven

2. Family-Level Reading

G2

G2 already had a real mismatch anchor from 台区线损大数据-月_周累计线损率统计分析.

The key failures remain:

1. archetype mismatch
2. bootstrap mismatch
3. request contract missing
4. column semantics missing

This is a mainline compiler-family gap.

G1-E

G1-E remains the only stable positive real-sample anchor.

Its current role is not to open a new scope but to act as the positive baseline against which future real-sample regressions are judged.

G3

G3 now has an executed real mismatch anchor.

The key finding is:

1. the real sample was executed
2. the sample did not stay in paginated_enrichment
3. the run collapsed into local_doc_pipeline
4. the result then failed closed

This is also a mainline compiler-family gap.

3. Scope Decision

The next bounded implementation scope should be:

1. mainline G3 real-sample archetype correction
2. followed by mainline G2 real-sample contract correction

The next scope should not be:

1. a boundary-family roadmap for G6/G7/G8
2. a deferred-family entry round for G4/G5

4. Reason

The strongest validation pressure still comes from unresolved mainline gaps.

As long as G3 and G2 both fail under real execution, opening boundary or deferred families would be scope drift.