claw/docs/superpowers/reports/2026-04-18-g3-p0-validation-report.md

G3 P0 Validation Report

Date: 2026-04-18 Scope: docs/superpowers/plans/2026-04-18-g3-paginated-enrichment-plan.md Phase 3 -> Phase 4 Archetype: G3 / paginated_enrichment Result: Passed

1. Conclusion

G3 的 P0-3 基线已经形成正式闭环。

当前 repo-local P0 样板 tests/fixtures/generated_scene/paginated_enrichment 已经稳定恢复并通过以下关键合同：

1. main_request
2. pagination_plan
3. enrichment_requests
4. join_keys
5. merge_or_dedupe_rules
6. export_plan

同时，G3 的 fail-closed 语义已经固定，至少覆盖：

1. join_key_missing
2. pagination_incomplete
3. export_only_without_business_chain

2. Validation Inputs

本轮 repo-local P0 校验基于以下资产：

1. Fixture:
   • tests/fixtures/generated_scene/paginated_enrichment/index.html
2. Canonical:
   • tests/fixtures/generated_scene/p0_canonical_answers/p0-3-paginated-enrichment.scene-ir.json
3. Tests:
   • tests/scene_generator_canonical_test.rs
   • tests/scene_generator_test.rs

关键回归命令：

cargo test --test scene_generator_canonical_test -- --nocapture
cargo test --test scene_generator_test -- --nocapture

3. P0 Restored Semantics

当前 P0-3 样板已经稳定恢复：

1. Main request
   • endpoint url: http://yx.gs.sgcc.com.cn/marketing/userList
   • response path: rows
2. Pagination plan
   • page field: page
   • page size field: pageSize
   • termination rule: stop_when_page_rows_empty
3. Enrichment request
   • endpoint url: http://yx.gs.sgcc.com.cn/marketing/userCharges
   • consumed field: custNo
4. Join key
   • custNo
5. Merge / dedupe rules
   • dedupe:custNo
   • aggregate:charge
6. Export plan
   • entry: exportExcel

4. Acceptance Checklist Result

对照 WS4 / WS5 的 P0 检查项，当前结果如下：

1. workflowArchetype = paginated_enrichment
2. mainRequest.responsePath = rows
3. paginationPlan.pageField = page
4. joinKeys = [custNo]
5. mergeOrDedupeRules 包含 aggregate:charge
6. exportPlan.entry = exportExcel
7. g3_join_key_resolved = true
8. localhost_dependency_candidate 未污染主业务链
9. readiness.level = A

5. Failure Taxonomy Baseline

本轮已被测试钉住的 G3 失败 taxonomy：

1. join_key_missing
2. pagination_incomplete
3. export_only_without_business_chain

对应测试：

1. paginated_enrichment_readiness_marks_join_key_missing_taxonomy
2. paginated_enrichment_readiness_marks_pagination_incomplete_taxonomy
3. paginated_enrichment_readiness_marks_export_only_without_business_chain_taxonomy

6. Final Status

对照 2026-04-18-g3-paginated-enrichment-plan.md：

1. P0 canonical 已冻结
2. P0 acceptance checklist 已转化为可执行测试
3. P0 failure taxonomy 已形成最小稳定集合
4. P0-3 当前可作为 G3 后续 family 扩展的统一校准源