# Send Connector B-First Plan

Date: 2026-07-10
Node: C29 / write-side connector route correction
Decision owner: user/business manager

## Decision

The selected send route is now:

1. **Primary route B: in-process / sidecar connector** that reuses the already logged-in `IMPlatformClient.exe` runtime and its existing message/file send classes.
2. **Fallback route A: constrained UI/RPA wrapper** only if B cannot attach, load, or invoke safely.
3. **Network replay/protocol reimplementation remains deferred** because it would require independently reproducing login/session/ack behavior.

This document supersedes the previous C15/R5 conclusion for future send work. The old conclusion was correct for the evidence available at that time: no write connector had been selected. This node records the newly approved route and the evidence that makes B worth trying first.

## Business goal

Expose controlled MCP actions for digital employees:

- `isphere_send_message`
- `isphere_send_file`

The implementation must preserve these business controls:

- target must be resolved from existing contact/group search results;
- text/file content must be previewed before execution;
- execution must use an `idempotency_key` and content hash;
- every outbound attempt must produce an audit record;
- early versions should support sandbox/test-target verification before normal production use.

## Static evidence summary

Offline package evidence under:

```text
runs/offline-evidence-intake/zyl-qqfile-20260709/
```

Relevant extracted binaries:

```text
zyl/Impp/IMPlatformClient.exe
zyl/Impp/smack.dll
zyl/Impp/IMPP.Interface.dll
zyl/Impp/IMPP.ServiceBase.dll
zyl/Impp/IMPP.Service.dll
zyl/Impp/TcpFileTransfer.dll
zyl/Impp/HYHC.IMPP.DAL.dll
```

Relevant IL snapshots:

```text
runs/offline-evidence-intake/zyl-qqfile-20260709/metadata/c28-il/IMPlatformClient.exe.il
runs/offline-evidence-intake/zyl-qqfile-20260709/metadata/c28-il/smack.dll.il
runs/offline-evidence-intake/zyl-qqfile-20260709/metadata/c28-il/IMPP.Interface.dll.il
runs/offline-evidence-intake/zyl-qqfile-20260709/metadata/c28-il/IMPP.Service.dll.il
runs/offline-evidence-intake/zyl-qqfile-20260709/metadata/c28-il/IMPP.ServiceBase.dll.il
```

## Text-send call chain

### Preferred sidecar candidate

`IMPlatformClient.exe` contains a high-level helper:

```text
IMPP.Client.Core.Plugins.Manager.AppContextManager.SendTxtMessageByJid(jid, chatType, content)
```

Observed behavior from IL:

- for direct/P2P chat, it gets a `P2PChatManager` from `IMPPManager.Instance`;
- it resolves a `Chat` by JID;
- it finds or opens a chat form;
- it calls `frmP2PChat.SendTxtMessage(content)`;
- for temporary/reserved group chat, it calls the corresponding room form send method.

This is the best B-route first target because it reuses the logged-in client's own state and UI/business rules.

### Central message construction candidate

`IMPlatformClient.exe` also contains:

```text
IMPP.Client.Core.MessageEngine.MessageScheduling.SendChatMessage(chat, msgText, toJid, messageType, isSaveMessage, msgGuid, IsReceipt)
```

Observed behavior from IL:

- reads local font/style settings;
- builds message body via `UtilsText.GetMessageStyleBodyText`;
- decides `chat` vs `groupchat`;
- creates `smack.packet.XmppMessage`;
- sets body, subject, offline flag, receipt flag, time, and message type;
- calls `chat.SendMessage(xmppMessage)`;
- optionally persists/parses message through `MessageManager.MessageParsing`.

This is the cleanest lower-level B candidate if the sidecar can obtain a valid `Chat` object from the running client context.

### Protocol bottom

`smack.dll` provides the real wire-send chain:

```text
com.vision.smack.Chat.SendMessage(XmppMessage)
  -> com.vision.smack.XMPPConnection.send(string)
  -> Sharp.Xmpp.Core.XmppCore.Send(string)
  -> stream.Write(...)
```

This proves that the send capability exists in the installed client binaries. It also shows why an external reimplementation is less attractive: it would need the same active connection, stanza format, message id, receipt, and session state.

## Important trap: plugin interface text send is not enough

`IMPP.Interface.dll` declares:

```text
IAppContextManager.SendP2PMessage(string pJid, string pMessage)
IAppContextManager.SendP2PFiles(UserInfo[] pUserInfo, string[] pFiles)
IAppContextManager.SendChatRoomMessage(string pRoomJid, string pMessage, string pluginID)
IAppContextManager.SendPluginMessage(string pluginID, int command, string para)
```

But the implementation of:

```text
IMPP.Client.Core.Plugins.Manager.AppContextManager.SendP2PMessage(...)
```

records the plugin call and then throws `NotImplementedException`.

Therefore the B route must **not** choose `SendP2PMessage` as the text-send entry. The sidecar should prefer `SendTxtMessageByJid` or, if necessary, `MessageScheduling.SendChatMessage` with an existing `Chat` object.

## File-send call chain

File sending appears split into upload plus file-message notification.

### Upload engine

`IMPP.ServiceBase.dll` defines `IFileTransfer`.

`IMPP.Service.dll` implements:

```text
IMPP.Service.BLL.FileTransfer.FileUpload(...)
IMPP.Service.BLL.FileTransfer.AsynFileUpload(...)
IMPP.Service.BLL.FileTransfer.FileDownload(...)
IMPP.Service.BLL.FileTransfer.SyncFileTransfer(...)
```

### Offline file send

`IMPlatformClient.exe` contains:

```text
IMPP.Client.OffLineFileSend.sendFile()
IMPP.Client.OffLineFileSend.trans_UploadCompleted(fileId)
```

Observed behavior:

- builds a generated file GUID;
- builds remote name as `filename____guid.ext`;
- uses `Config.ServerInfo.HTTPFileServer` and `FileTransferManager.GetDomain`;
- creates `FileUploadPara`;
- calls `IMPPManager.Instance.Service.FileTransfer.FileUpload(uploadPara)`;
- after upload completion, creates an `OFFLINE_FILE_TRANSFER;...` message body;
- calls `Chat.sendFileMessage(...)`;
- sets packet id to `fileId` and records metadata.

### Native TCP file transfer

`TcpFileTransfer.dll` is native and exposes strings/exports indicating:

```text
Send
SendFile
GetTcpFileMsgGuid
_StartWaitForSendFileThread@8
_StartRecvFileThread@24
```

This is a candidate for online/TCP file transfer, but the first B route should use the managed offline-file path because it is closer to the normal client business flow and already integrates upload metadata with XMPP file messages.

## Proposed sidecar architecture

```text
Go MCP Server
  -> controlled action contract and audit
  -> C# WinHelper / Sidecar command
  -> B-route sidecar adapter
  -> running IMPlatformClient context
  -> existing AppContextManager / MessageScheduling / OffLineFileSend / smack.dll
```

The sidecar should be a narrow adapter, not a general-purpose remote code executor.

### Candidate sidecar operations

```text
version
self_check
probe_client_runtime
probe_send_entrypoints
resolve_runtime_jid
preview_send_message
send_message_after_approval
preview_send_file
send_file_after_approval
read_send_audit
```

The first implementation slice should stop before real production send:

```text
version
self_check
probe_client_runtime
probe_send_entrypoints
```

Then run a live sandbox observation before enabling `send_message_after_approval`.

## B-route validation gates

### Gate B1: runtime discovery

Pass condition:

- find a running `IMPlatformClient.exe` process;
- record PID, bitness, install path, module list summary;
- confirm the discovered path matches the extracted evidence family;
- confirm whether the sidecar must be x86 or x64.

Stop condition:

- no logged-in process;
- process bitness incompatible with available sidecar build;
- module names differ too much from the extracted package.

### Gate B2: entrypoint availability

Pass condition:

- confirm `IMPlatformClient.exe` exposes `AppContextManager` and `MessageScheduling` in the runtime module set;
- confirm `smack.dll` is loaded or loadable from the same install directory;
- confirm `IMPP.Interface.dll` and `IMPP.Service*.dll` are present.

Stop condition:

- app is not .NET Framework / cannot inspect CLR runtime safely;
- required assemblies are missing;
- only `SendP2PMessage` is available but `SendTxtMessageByJid`/`MessageScheduling` cannot be reached.

### Gate B3: non-mutating dynamic observation

Pass condition:

- during one operator-approved manual test send, observe the expected chain:
  - `SendTxtMessageByJid` or UI send method;
  - `MessageScheduling.SendChatMessage`;
  - `Chat.SendMessage`;
  - `XMPPConnection.send`;
- capture only redacted method names, argument shape, message id/hash, and success/ack indicator.

Stop condition:

- method chain differs from static evidence;
- no success/ack indicator can be mapped;
- message id/idempotency cannot be correlated.

### Gate B4: sidecar dry run

Pass condition:

- sidecar can resolve the target JID/chat type;
- sidecar can build a preview object without sending;
- preview contains target, content hash, connector, and proposed entrypoint;
- audit event is appended.

Stop condition:

- no deterministic target resolution;
- preview cannot distinguish direct vs group chat;
- no auditable dry-run object.

### Gate B5: one sandbox send

Pass condition:

- one explicit test target only;
- one idempotency key only;
- one message content hash only;
- success/ack or local sent-record evidence captured;
- duplicate retry with same idempotency key is rejected locally.

Stop condition:

- duplicate send risk;
- wrong target risk;
- no post-send verification.

## A-route fallback

A remains the backup route if B cannot be made reliable.

A should not be arbitrary desktop control. It should expose only:

```text
search_contact(query)
open_conversation(target)
write_draft(text)
verify_draft(target, text_hash)
send_after_approval(approval_id)
upload_file(path)
verify_send_result()
```

A-route fallback is activated when any of these happen:

- B cannot attach/probe safely;
- required runtime classes are unavailable in the logged-in process;
- B can observe but cannot invoke without unstable side effects;
- B cannot provide idempotency/audit guarantees;
- sidecar bitness/runtime mismatch is too costly to resolve in the current cycle.

## MCP contract impact

The MCP business tools should not expose B/A internals directly. They should keep the stable user-facing shape:

```text
isphere_send_message(target_type, target_id, content_text, mode, idempotency_key, content_sha256)
isphere_send_file(target_type, target_id, file_path, mode, idempotency_key, file_sha256)
```

Connector metadata should show the route:

```text
connector = "implatform-sidecar" | "uia-rpa"
connector_stage = "preview" | "sandbox_send" | "production"
```

## Next implementation loop

R6b B-route preview/dry-run contract is now complete. `isphere_send_message` is registered as preview/dry-run only, validates target/content-hash/idempotency input, appends redacted audit JSONL, and blocks production with all side-effect flags false.

Next node should be **R6c online sandbox-send evidence gate**:

1. Prepare or collect one operator-approved sandbox send evidence package.
2. Use one explicit sandbox target, one content hash, and one idempotency key.
3. Observe success/ack or local sent-record evidence.
4. Prove duplicate retry with the same idempotency key is locally rejected before any second send.
5. Capture method names, argument shape, IDs/hashes, status booleans, and refs only.
6. Do not enable production `send_message_after_approval` until the evidence gate passes.

## Current status

B is selected as the primary send/file-send route. Runtime discovery, entrypoint metadata preflight, and preview/dry-run audit are in place. A remains the fallback and now has concrete UIA selector/offline-blocker classifier support. Production send remains blocked until dynamic observation and one approved sandbox send prove success/ack behavior.